Best Game Console 2023: Should you Buy PlayStation, Xbox or Switch?

The PlayStation 5 represents the pinnacle in new-gen gaming, offering solid 4K@60fps (or even 120fps with a compatible TV) gameplay alongside lightning-fast load times thanks to the inclusion of a custom-designed SSD – although it is a little small at 825GB, and unlike the Xbox Series X, it’s pretty difficult (and pricey) to upgrade the internal storage. 

When it comes to performance, expect ray-tracing, high-quality textures, improved particle effects and a generally higher fidelity experience than that of the PS4, but it’s arguably the DualSense controller that truly separates it from the competition.

Sony’s DualSense controller sports adjustable triggers, meaning the bumpers can better simulate the trigger of a gun or pulling back a bow before firing, and the advanced haptic motors make things feel much more realistic too. The two technologies combined offer a huge step forward compared to the Xbox controller, which offers minimal differences at best.  

There may not be a lower-powered variant like the Xbox Series S, but there is the disc-less PS5 Digital available at a discount without compromising on next-gen performance.

Be warned though: the PS5 is a chonk, no matter which variant you go for.  

The Xbox Series X is Microsoft’s answer to new-gen gaming, offering the same 4K@120fps performance with ray-tracing, high-quality textures and improved particle effects as the PS5, and although not quite as fast as Sony’s bespoke SSD, the inclusion of an SSD means games are snappy too.

There’s a large library of games available to play, offering backward compatibility all the way back to the original Xbox – something that the PS5 can’t quite compete with, only offering compatibility with PS4 titles outside of its PS Now service. 

The design is much more muted than the competition, sporting an all-black design with green highlights within the vent atop the console, but it still stands tall at 30cm.

It’s a solid contender for the title of best console, when it comes down to it, the ‘safe’ update to the Xbox controller is what lets it down – while Sony went all-in on all aspects of the next-gen console experience, it seems Microsoft focused only on the tower itself. 

The Xbox Series S doesn’t offer the same high framerate 4K gameplay as the Series X or PS5, but it does offer key upgrades including the speedy SSD and the updated Xbox UI, and it’s much cheaper than the hero consoles too.

In fact, if you’ve got a 1440p display, it could be the ideal console for you – especially when you consider that it’s much smaller than the other next-gen consoles, making for a better TV-side companion. It could also be a cheap-ish way to get your hands on Microsoft exclusive titles if you primarily play on another console, especially given the company’s purchase of Bethesda. 

Make no mistake though – it’s not as powerful as its bigger brother, and it can’t even run games with Xbox One X enhancements, so steer clear if you’re currently using the last-gen One X. 

The Nintendo Switch (OLED) doesn’t offer a boost in graphical power like some might’ve hoped, but as the name suggests, it does sport a larger 7in OLED display for an improved handheld gaming experience with more vivid colours and deeper blacks. Zelda has never looked as good as it does on the Switch OLED!

It’s more than just a display upgrade though; there’s improved battery life compared to the original 2017 variant of Switch, boasting between 4.5 and 9 hours of life depending on the game you’re playing. The console fixes a few long-time complaints too, including the flimsy kickstand, replaced this time around by a much sturdier option, and improved button shapes too.

If you’ve got the newer version of the Nintendo Switch with improved battery life then the OLED model probably isn’t worth the upgrade, but if you’ve got an older 2017 release Switch, or you’re yet to pick one up, the OLED model is worth the money.  

Nintendo’s most popular console right now is predictably unusual. The Switch is a sort of handheld/home console hybrid – you can connect it to your TV to play on the big screen, or take it with you on the go as a high-powered handheld, with various different control configurations for each setup. While the design looks a little dated compared to the newer Switch OLED model, the two handhelds offer the same game experience, with no graphical enhancements from the upgraded model. 

That said, you don’t always get to play the latest AAA titles on the Switch due to the lack of graphical power available, but there is a huge array of Nintendo exclusive and indie titles available to buy or download.

It’s the console you’ll need if you want to play the latest Zelda and Mario titles, and it’s the best bet if you want versions of huge games like Skyrim that you can take with you on the go.

The Nvidia Shield TV may seem expensive for a media streamer, but the games available on Google Play on the system are fairly cheap – and there’s plenty more on offer too. 

While the Shield offers all the same features that a standard media streamer would (on-demand TV, etc) it also offers a number of Shield-exclusive games that are pretty power-intensive, and it offers support for a range of Bluetooth controllers too.

It also boasts an exclusive subscription service that provides you with a vast library of games to play, and you also have the option to buy the latest PC games to play directly on the Shield via GeForce Now, too.

If the standard Nintendo Switch isn’t portable enough for your needs, the smaller Switch Lite might tick your boxes. It offers the same core Nintendo Switch experience, complete with the latest Switch titles, but with a smaller 5.5in display and a lighter form factor. 

However, unlike the standard console, it isn’t hybrid – it’s a handheld console only, with no way to connect it to a TV. The Joy-Cons aren’t removable either, which might cause a few problems with gesture-based titles.

Still, it’s cheaper than the standard Nintendo Switch and for those that primarily play handheld consoles, the TV-less nature of the Lite isn’t a huge issue. 

It’s not the next-gen console, but the Xbox One S is a great console for casual gamers.

It’s smaller and lighter than the Xbox Series X and the power unit is built-in which is also a nice touch. Although the Xbox One S supports 4K resolution, it’s limited to video playback so you’ll have to hold out for the Xbox Series X for 4K gaming.

Just be sure to get one at the right price; as stock dwindles, we’re seeing some retailers stock the console for between $/£200-300. Considering that was the price when it was the current-gen console, that’s too much to pay. We’d advise paying no more than $/£200.

The PS4 Slim is pretty much exactly what it says on the tin, a smaller version of the original PS4 in a smaller (more rounded) design, and with the launch of the PS5, it’s cheaper than ever.

With a library of games at your fingertips and releases continuing for some time, there’s no better time to get your hands on a PS4 Slim. 

Existing PS4 owners won’t need to upgrade as the internals are almost identical. Although the slim PS4 has HDR support, that isn’t exclusive as it’s also been introduced to the launch PS4 with a software update.

As with the Xbox One S, make sure you pick one up for the right price as some retailers are charging over the odds for the old console. If it costs more than £200, we recommend shopping around.